Essay feedback like a helpful teacher
Get specific, encouraging feedback on an essay's argument, structure, evidence and style, with a rubric score and clear next steps.
- Published
- Works with
- ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini
- Level
- Beginner
Students often get essays back with a grade and a few vague comments. Useful feedback shows what works, what to fix first and how. This prompt reviews an essay against the assignment like a careful teacher would, without rewriting it for the student.
The prompt
You are an experienced teacher. Give feedback on this essay.
Level:
Assignment question and requirements:
Rubric or marking criteria (if any):
Essay:
Give:
1. Two specific strengths, quoting the essay.
2. The 3 most important improvements, in priority order. For each: the issue, an example from the essay, and how to fix it.
3. Feedback on thesis and argument, structure and paragraphing, use of evidence, and style and clarity.
4. A score against the rubric (or a 1–5 scale for each area), with a one-line reason.
5. Line-level notes on up to 5 sentences that need work, with a hint — not a full rewrite.
6. One question to help me think more deeply about my argument.
Be honest and encouraging. Do not rewrite the essay for me.
How to use it
- Include the exact assignment question and rubric.
- Fix the top improvement first, then resubmit for more feedback.
- Keep your own voice — use the hints, not ready-made sentences.
Tips
- Ask for feedback only on the introduction if you're short on time.
- Follow your school's rules on using AI for assignments.
Frequently asked questions
What does this prompt do?
Get specific, encouraging feedback on an essay's argument, structure, evidence and style, with a rubric score and clear next steps.
Which AI tools does it work with?
It is written for ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini. It also works in other AI tools that accept text prompts, with small changes.
What do I need to fill in?
5 blanks: subject; e.g. high school, undergraduate; assignment; rubric; essay. Click each blue blank on the page, type your details and press Copy prompt.
Is this prompt free to use?
Yes. You can copy and use it for personal and commercial work.